FAQ Search
Memberlist Usergroups
Profile
  Forum Statistics Register
 Log in to check your private messages
Log in to check your private messages
Moonpod Homepage Starscape Information Mr. Robot Information Free Game Downloads Starscape Highscore Table
demo vs no-demo
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Discussion Pod Forum Index -> Independent Game Development View previous topic :: View next topic  
 Author
Message
Poo Bear
Pod Team
Pod Team


Joined: 14 Oct 2002
Posts: 4121
Location: Sheffield, UK



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 1:19 pm    Post subject: demo vs no-demo Reply with quote

<warning_rant_detected>

I think NOT having a free demo is a really overt and nasty example of capitalist exploitation (I'm looking at you Starcraft2) - sorry but this is one thing I've noticed is on the increase and I really don't like it. Nintendo resisted demos for a long time, then quietly did a test with demos of WorldOfGoo and a few other games and then even more quietly removed the demos.

If you give a free demo then people can see for themselves whether they want it or not. If you don't have a demo, but DO have a big enough marketing / hype budget then you can sell more, because people who do not actually want your product will buy it because of the hype inflating their expectations.

I think it demonstrates a contempt for the player. It should never be acceptable or desirable to make money from people who actually do not want what you sell.

To be fair there is one acceptable rebuttal. If you give a player something for nothing (a demo) then they have less commitment to exploring everything it has to offer and are more likely to dismiss it. If a player has invested in something then they are more likely to commit to it and invest the time needed to begin to master it and extract all the goodness from it. The easiest way to get someone to commit to something is to make them pay for it.

There is also a more practical explanation, that I like less, but is reasonable. If you let people play a 60min demo then a large percentage will extract 60mins of fun from the experience and be adequately satisfied at that. Those people would have happily played for many hours, but don't feel any deep compulsion to do so and therefore will be happy with just a demo. The end result is a lot of lost sales to people who would have enjoyed playing - they aren't fanatics by any means, but could have had a good few hours of fun if the hype had been allowed to lure them in.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Weeble
Starscape Jedi
Starscape Jedi


Joined: 25 Apr 2003
Posts: 1143
Location: Glasgow, Scotland



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 3:36 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I've heard one reasonable argument against unrestricted demos for games with a significant multiplayer component - if you have a demo with unrestricted access to the multiplayer parts it will be a massive vector for gold-spammers and phishers and other nefarious types who will prey on or just annoy your legitimate players, but if you place too many restrictions on demo players to prevent this they will have a frustrating and unrepresentative experience. That's one reason for limited refer-a-friend schemes - it's much harder for bad guys to create huge numbers of throwaway accounts.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
Rup



Joined: 19 May 2003
Posts: 363
Location: London, UK



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 3:41 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

There is the cost / benefit too: Starcraft is going to sell anyway, and once it's sold enough it might get by on word-of-mouth, or even just word-of-mouth from the beta. It takes development effort to strip a game down to a demoable size and test etc. They can't use the full install for a restricted playtime demo as you do because it's a 7-8 GB download.

I haven't been following this - I don't know if a demo's coming later or not. I'm certainly guilty of buying games on name alone sometimes.
Back to top
View user's profile
Poo Bear
Pod Team
Pod Team


Joined: 14 Oct 2002
Posts: 4121
Location: Sheffield, UK



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 4:00 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Weeble wrote:
I've heard one reasonable argument against unrestricted demos for games with a significant multiplayer component - if you have a demo with unrestricted access to the multiplayer parts it will be a massive vector for gold-spammers and phishers and other nefarious types who will prey on or just annoy your legitimate players.


That's an interesting point about those evil gold farmers and griefers. I hate to admit it, but I've done some griefing myself. Not in demos, but in subscribed mmos (ultima online), I remember dressing up as a jester (a fairly rare outfit) and attempting to lure the innocent away from the safety of town with tales of fun and games nearby. Only to turn vicious once we'd crested the hill and then mugging the poor unfortunate. As a subscriber there were repercussions for this behaviour, like being chased by the victims rather large and angry guild for a mile or two, unable to use shops in that town, attacked by guards, etc. I think without those repercussions such behaviour would be disastrous for the game.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Poo Bear
Pod Team
Pod Team


Joined: 14 Oct 2002
Posts: 4121
Location: Sheffield, UK



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 4:06 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rup wrote:
There is the cost / benefit too: Starcraft is going to sell anyway, and once it's sold enough it might get by on word-of-mouth, or even just word-of-mouth from the beta. It takes development effort to strip a game down to a demoable size and test etc. They can't use the full install for a restricted playtime demo as you do because it's a 7-8 GB download.


Yes, that put me off with the demo for A.P.B - I was interested in the demo to check it out, but they hadn't been able to reduce the file size so it was an 8Gig download. The download got turned off part way through for some unknown reason and I never got round to starting it up again. With something like that they would probably have to make a special level to properly restrict the content to get a small demo. I say it would be worth it, I'm not going to buy the game without it, but then I may not be a 'normal' player.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Konedima
Grammar Police
Grammar Police


Joined: 25 Oct 2003
Posts: 1068
Location: Sydney, Land of Censorship



PostPosted: Thu Aug 05, 2010 10:34 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Poo Bear wrote:
Yes, that put me off with the demo for A.P.B - I was interested in the demo to check it out, but they hadn't been able to reduce the file size so it was an 8Gig download. The download got turned off part way through for some unknown reason and I never got round to starting it up again. With something like that they would probably have to make a special level to properly restrict the content to get a small demo. I say it would be worth it, I'm not going to buy the game without it, but then I may not be a 'normal' player.

Just be glad you had the opportunity (although I'm fairly sure I've complained about this before) - at least you had the opportunity! They haven't, and as far as I'm aware, never intend to, release APB here, because they're too cheap to set up servers.

Sorry, off topic, but it ****** me off. So does not releasing demos, although these days it's extremely common not to release a demo for your BIG titles (I'm not sure when I last saw a demo of a GTA game... but does that stop me buying them? Nope).
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Poo Bear
Pod Team
Pod Team


Joined: 14 Oct 2002
Posts: 4121
Location: Sheffield, UK



PostPosted: Fri Aug 06, 2010 12:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Credit to Microsoft, I love all the demos on X360. I must have filled that 40Gig hard drive up 5 times over downloading all the arcade and xna demos.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Konedima
Grammar Police
Grammar Police


Joined: 25 Oct 2003
Posts: 1068
Location: Sydney, Land of Censorship



PostPosted: Fri Aug 06, 2010 12:02 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Poo Bear wrote:
I love all the demos on X360

Likewise. When I got my PS3 I was surprised by how many games didn't have demos, especially PSN (or PS3 in general) exclusive games. Mandatory demos on Xbox might be a bit harder for the developer, but it makes my life a lot easier (and cheaper).

Poo Bear wrote:
xna demos

Also something we can't get. This isn't AS MUCH the fault of the publisher, I can understand indie devs not being able to afford a few thousand dollars to have their game rated by the OFLC. Here's the thing - they don't have to. Only games sold in Australia are subject to their overzealous refusal of classification. Games sold elsewhere - say, the internet, as long as the website isn't actually based in Australia - are fine. Importing and possession of games refused classification is perfectly legal (New Zealanders aren't so lucky on this part, as there are several games over there for which possession is a crime).
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
myy



Joined: 15 Nov 2017
Posts: 155



PostPosted: Fri Jun 22, 2018 1:53 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

The toronto raptors jersey ancients said: "Shenhua oakley sunglasses cheap province bcbg max azria lock toms shoes outlet red dust, suddenly jets jerseys Huazhi pandora feel new balance old." montblanc One of nike air force the dsquared2 "Sudden" polo ralph lauren outlet words are babyliss flat iron flexible and houston rockets now ray ban wayfarer open milwaukee bucks jersey the asics outlet characteristics raiders jerseys of adidas superstar the open seahawks jerseys flowers.


Perhaps sacramento kings an rams jerseys ice burberry outlet store and tommy hilfiger outlet snow polo ralph lauren outlet online bitter cold morning, oakley sunglasses outlet perhaps timberland boots a ravens jerseys sunny and ny jersey warm afternoon, winter, converse chucks one nike shoes of the warriors jerseys hay tommy hilfiger among the nike schoenen hay, nike roshe run suddenly uggs outlet there are nike running shoes one or thomas sabo uk two oakley red new orleans pelicans jersey flowers in gucci store the rolex probe hollister online brain. Because it guciheaven outlet is only nike air huarache sporadic nike roshe run one falcons jerseys or giants jerseys two, coach outlet online it is difficult michael kors handbags to attract people's barbour womens jackets attention. michael kors bags Even bcbg max if oakley sunglasses noted, reebok and mcm handbags thought ferragamo it was kate spade an gucci shoes store unknown fivefingers wild denver nuggets jerseys flower chaos longchamp taschen of kate spade handbags the barbour jacket outlet biological clock, unable to ecco shoes outlet bear christian louboutin the replica watches temper adidas.se of thomas sabo anxious to hastily mcm bags opened up. longchamp outlet Heart can not air max help louboutin shoes but toms shoes outlet some cheap nba jerseys for it nike store uk pity, because the michael kors winter cold will bears jerseys soon give adidas online shop it punishment, montre homme let michael kors purses it pay marc by marc jacobs the converse sneakers price of ralph lauren love out burberry sale of suns jersey the versace outlet limelight.


Did not birkenstock think, pandora charms after rolex watches a cheap shoes few moncler mens jackets days, nike soccer shoes the ralph lauren original blossoming the north face dry bushes replica rolex actually parajumpers parkas appeared in belstaff mens jackets the puma online shop eyes cheap jack wolfskin of roshe run a polo ralph lauren large cheap oakley bright hollisterco yellow. nba jerseys Approached a michael kors look, a blossoming yellow zapatillas nike flowers nike free in broncos jerseys the faint green branches on nike.se the tommy hilfiger online branches, the sunglasses for women front ray ban sunglasses of fidget spinner the louboutin branches ray ban occhiali there are bulls jerseys many bulging buds, burberry mustering the chi hair strength, mizuno as burberry outlet if coach outlet store at skechers canada any pandora bracelet time bloom. tory burch Although the arrangement redskins jerseys of true religion branches hugo boss outlet online is slightly oakley frogskins messy, longchamp handbags but the shape okc jerseys of each nike.dk flower cheap nfl jerseys is oakley sunglasses very Zhouzheng, nike roshe run leaflets bracts longchamp above utah jazz jersey is longchamp handbags a retro jordans long crown tube, above coach bags outlet the under armour shoes tube north face is nfl jerseys a converse outlet trumpet-like michael kors flowers. Most airmax of the flowers consist burberry outlet store of six petals, michael kors bags and roshes there are jordans for sale five jack wolfskin outlet online petals. The reebok outlet color of the timberland outlet middle of nike free 5.0 the coach factory outlet online vase browns jerseys into the dark, the middle michael kors handbags of 76ers jerseys a thin hermes belt flower stamens, coach factory online flowers timberland outlet stained designer handbags with nike air max many azcardinals jerseys pollen, issued michael jordan bursts of faint aroma, from pandora jewellery australia time to ray bans time northface attracted numerous air max thea bees oakley sunglasses outlet come north face canada honey.


This kind rayban of nike air max short kate spade bags deciduous polo outlet online shrub the north face outlet seems to be so elegant hogan mens shoes and elegant on true religion outlet the new balance top, it is extremely coach usa common, giuseppe zanotti always ray ban wayfarer clustered cheap jerseys lying burberry outlet online on ralph lauren outlet online the ray ban zonnebril ground or toms.com squatting in tods womens shoes the corner. The michael kors uhren cloak panthers jerseys of the cheap oakley sunglasses branches without hermes outlet any 49ers jerseys rules to adidas yeezy shoes cross, oakley sunglasses it mizuno running shoes seems barbour jackets that air max some nike air max of adidas zx flux my own ray ban uk way, debauchery. marc by marc jacobs Nevertheless, vans schuhe it is the prada handbags ability jaguars jerseys to feel michael kors handbags the rolex watches spring and lacoste shirts fighting gafas oakley the polo outlet wind birkenstock taschen deutschland of the wind in north face jackets no nike tn way nj jerseys plum giuseppe zanotti sneakers blossom. Just north face outlet pay attention, levis jeans even colts jerseys in the "is uhren shop a cliff Baizhang polo outlet store ice" in swarovski crystal the winter, buccaneers jerseys it belstaff womens jackets is eagles jerseys not ed hardy clothing difficult ray ban sunglasses to coach bags outlet find burberry handbags outlet it nike air max "squid" pretty detroit pistons shadows. Its barbour jackets flowering nike air max thea period is earlier burberry than memphis grizzlies jersey plum, slightly later than oakley sunglasses waxy, is nike free run the nike mercurial vapor earliest christian louboutin outlet spring ralph lauren outlet online of vans shoes the birkenstock deutschland flower miami heat messenger. swarovski crystal It is the longchamp grass-roots stone island body with the plum blossom, atlanta hawks jerseys narcissus supra footwear and camellia, handbags outlet won nike running shoes the the north face "four friends coach usa in nike huarache the toms shoes outlet snow," nba jerseys the oakley sunglasses Ya said, and nfl jerseys have air max 90 a "spring" converse shoes reputation.


Ying nba jerseys Chun nike store who embodies swarovski jewelry this asics unruly personality is often caused by the prada ancient true religion jeans women love prada tracksuits to address jimmy choo the toms outlet online shortcomings of ray bans the official jimmy choo outlet culture nike.com of the resonance. Bai barbour mens jackets Juyi appreciation of cheap basketball shoes the spring "Jin guess bags Ying oakley sunglasses cheap Tsui rayban calyx north face backpacks with spring celine outlet cold, yellow flowers tory burch handbags in juicy couture a chiefs jerseys few?", philipp plein clothing To remind cheap oakley sunglasses you packers jerseys not to soccer shoes outlet wait for the nike running "Spring", "the status michael kors outlet online of hornets jersey the king and the eyeglasses stores way purses and handbags to vans outlet the www.tommyhilfiger.nl road, valentino outlet Mo tommy hilfiger canada for cheap oakley sunglasses Manjing [jīng] lunette ray ban He also adopted anthropomorphic ferragamo shoes approach, oakley under the north face jackets guise pandora charms of coach outlet sale the hogan sito ufficiale tone of moncler women jackets the ralph lauren spring, inviting ray ban outlet Liu Lang coach outlet usa in the polo ralph lauren flowers air max 2014 when the first burberry online shop time swarovski australia to see hollister clothing the cowboys jerseys style philipp plein of the chi flat iron spring, in order new balance shoes to fitflop shoes celebrate swarovski the years true religion jeans outlet of g by guess good friend burberry sale Liu jordan shoes Yuxi's clank red bottom iron ray ban outlet and suave [t tǎng] relojes romantic. bills jerseys "Fortunately, true religion jeans men Song new balance Yun air jordan retro [yn] ralph lauren polo similar salvatore ferragamo to skechers womens shoes the plant, dsquared2 outlet not with peach Lee polo ralph open, ray ban pas cher apricot adidas Qi dare mcm handbags to Jun pandora charms Jun, no flowers nike factory and cheap jerseys it seems." In the nike fu?ballschuhe peach and thomas sabo jewellery plum long champ is dolphins jerseys often cheap jerseys used to orlando magic jersey saturistically prominent in the Tang Dynasty, seemingly timberland inadvertently versace a coach black friday "do patriots jerseys not ray-ban sunglasses follow peach polo ralph lauren Lee open" in ralph lauren online shop fact hidden deliberately los angeles lakers whom oakley sunglasses the highest saints jerseys praise, so hollister adhere to bengals jerseys their fred perry polos political calvin klein outlet views, several nike air max times woolrich womens jackets demoted vikings jerseys Liu juicy couture outlet Lang Elated, mbt womens shoes it is veneta used.


Han coach factory outlet Qi of jordan shoes the Northern polo ralph lauren Song Dynasty is also a steelers jerseys soft red bottom spot washington wizards jersey for hilfiger online shop the coach bags outlet spring. iphone 4s cases "Han Qi purses and handbags is the abercrombie Northern puma shoes outlet Song Dynasty burberry outlet store Ming Chen, is adidas sneakers an outstanding michael kors australia politician, ferragamo shoes military strategist, is portland trail blazers jersey also true religion outlet a poet." cheap michael kors Han salomon schuhe Qi nfl jerseys is hollister co the Northern adidas shoes Song coach factory outlet online Dynasty kate spade outlet minister, omega watches is cheap jerseys an c&c beanies outstanding supra shoes politician, military strategist, burberry outlet online is michael kors also a ralph lauren factory store poet. michael kors outlet He and mcm handbags Fan Zhongyan is a cross, in the bottega veneta border titans jerseys together with air jordan shoes the lac jersey northwest, cheap michael kors good skechers outlet governance, michael kors against coach outlet the toms outlet Western Xia, although michael kors outlet the hoodies store ultimate defeat, but michael kors outlet online also Granville mcm backpack shocked lacoste the spurs jerseys enemy; in chargers jerseys the jordan retro central indiana pacers jersey together pandora canada with their implementation coach outlet online of replica watches the "Qingli New Deal", advocate rectification prada outlet officials, hermes birkin bag selection of asics gel talent chrome hearts rings The And finally soccer shoes expelled prada outlet from christian louboutin shoes the court against burberry the false ralph lauren polo accusations against links of london charms the Herms Pas Cher New Deal ugg australia forces, coach shop and hollister co was hogan demoted. nike roshe run With cheap ray ban this air max 2014 experience, replica watches the michael kors uk rich politicians minnesota timberwolves jersey feel fendi the bright rolex replica spring new balance outlet branches of belstaff jackets outlet the flowers on polo ralph lauren the prada shoes bright yellow flowers, cheap jerseys unyielding, can easton bats not help rayban but nike air max heartfelt texans jerseys sentiment celtics jersey - ushered ferragamo in michael kors v?skor the bright michael kors outlet online sale spring fred perry outlet is not to givenchy shoes outlet make cavaliers jersey their nike shoes own meet, but hope dansko shoes outlet And flowers under armour outlet and red bottom shoes thousands ralph lauren outlet of michael kors outlet online flowers easton bats were michael kors outlet online sale spit fragrance. I do not ipad mini cases know the lions jerseys poem is hidden in the hilfiger outlet helpless interpretation of the opponent, or armani outlet online firmly adhere mont blanc pens to the adidas superstar beginning mavericks jerseys of the nike huarache heart?

swarovski online shop
Back to top
View user's profile
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Discussion Pod Forum Index -> Independent Game Development All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group